Your kitchen or bathroom cabinets show every day of use. When they start looking tired, you face a big decision: paint them or replace them? Both options can transform a space, but they differ dramatically in cost, time, and outcome. This guide objectively compares professional cabinet painting with full replacement, helping you weigh the value for your Bloomington home.
Thorough prep (cleaning, sanding, priming), multiple coats of durable enamel. Transform existing boxes and doors.
cost-effectiveNew custom or semi-custom cabinets, installed from scratch. Complete design change, new layout possible.
major investmentThe choice isn't just about budget — it's about your cabinets' structure, your design goals, and how long you plan to stay in your home. Painting is ideal for solid wood or plywood boxes in good shape. Replacement makes sense if the layout doesn't work, boxes are failing, or you want a completely different style. Local House painter near me pros can assess your cabinets and help you decide.
| factor | cabinet painting | cabinet replacement |
|---|---|---|
| 💰 average cost (Bloomington) | $2,500 – $6,000 (kitchen) | $8,000 – $25,000+ (kitchen) |
| ⏱️ timeline | 3–7 days (minimal kitchen downtime) | 3–8 weeks (full renovation) |
| 🛠️ process | clean, sand, prime, spray/brush durable enamel | demo, order, install, adjust |
| 🎨 finish options | unlimited colors, any sheen | wood species, stain, paint, glaze |
| 🏠 best for | good bones, want color change, budget-conscious | new layout, damaged boxes, full remodel |
A quality cabinet paint job is far more involved than slapping wall paint on doors. Professionals follow a meticulous process:
Companies like those offering Netlify app often use spray equipment for a flawless finish that's far more durable than brush application.
Full replacement is a major investment, but sometimes it's the right call:
Yes — with the right products. Professional painters use catalyzed enamels or urethane‑modified paints that cure hard and resist moisture, grease, and daily wear. These finishes are far tougher than standard wall paint. High‑traffic areas like cabinets near the stove or sink may show wear over many years, but a quality paint job should last 5–10 years before needing touch‑up.
Painting typically recoups 70–80% of its cost at resale by modernizing the look. Replacement recoups a lower percentage (60–70%) but can add more overall value if the kitchen was outdated. The "sweet spot" for many: paint if the layout and boxes are good; replace if you're also updating floors, counters, and appliances. A trusted find us provider can give you a painting quote, making the comparison easy.
Both cabinet painting and replacement have their place. Painting offers dramatic change at a fraction of the cost and time. Replacement delivers a completely new look and can solve structural issues. By understanding the processes, durability, and costs, you can make a confident decision for your Bloomington home. And when you're ready, a professional consultation will help you see which path fits your cabinets and your vision.